The put that pays more also loses less. Sell it anyway?
Two puts, the same strike, the same expiration. One pays 75, the other 190. If both stocks fall to the same price below the strike and both puts are assigned, the put that paid more leaves the smaller loss. So the premium column settles it. Except that it leaves out the one thing you will be holding when the trade goes wrong.
You have 5,000 set aside and two puts in front of you. Both stocks trade at 50. Both puts have a 50 strike and expire on the same Friday. The put on Stock A pays 0.75 a share, 75 for the contract. The put on Stock B pays 1.90, or 190. The numbers are an illustration, not a real security.
Most of us look at the 190 and the decision is made. Before you make it, run the bad case.
The richer put wins the bad case too
Assume either stock closes at 40 that Friday and its put is assigned. You pay 50 a share, 5,000, for shares now worth 4,000. On A you keep the 75, so your loss on paper is 925. On B you keep the 190, so it is 810.
The put that paid more lost less. That is not a trick of the example. When both stocks finish at the same price below the strike, whatever that price is, B stays 115 ahead because it paid 115 more. What the two stocks do after that is a different matter, and it is where the rest of this article goes.
Notice the other number. At 40, either trade leaves you down more than 800, even after keeping the premium. That gap is what people mean when they call selling puts picking up pennies in front of a steamroller. The saying is about the size of the pennies. It is silent about what you are holding after the steamroller has passed. So is the premium.
What the 190 tells you, and what it cannot
Even with the same stock price, strike and expiration, the larger premium can reflect expectations of bigger price swings in B's shares. It cannot tell you why B pays more, and it cannot tell you whether you would still want B's shares at 40. That is a question about the business, and nothing on the option chain answers it. So we answer it first, with a number from outside the market.
Put a value next to each price
Our floor starts with an independent estimate of what the business is worth, built from its finances rather than its stock chart. Research firms publish such estimates, often under the name fair value. We want the stock trading below that estimate, and our strike further below it.
Can you trust the estimate?
An estimate is only as good as what is behind it, so run three checks before you lean on one.
- Check when it was written and what has happened since. A report is only as current as its date. New results, a change of guidance or management, a lawsuit or other material news since then make it stale until it is refreshed.
- Check whether analysts have stopped lowering their forecasts for the company's profits. If the forecasts keep falling, the value estimate may be cut too, and the stock may not be cheap after all.
- Treat a value of 68 as an estimate, not an exact price. Change the assumptions a little and the number moves. That is why the strike goes well below it, not at it.
On the day you would sell the two puts, an estimate puts Stock A's value near 68 and Stock B's near 38. Hold those against the prices.
A trades at 50. A recent report values it near 68, nothing material has happened since, and its profit forecasts have remained steady. Your 50 strike sits well below it, so if you are assigned you buy at a price the estimate already calls a discount. We call the gap between the estimated value of 68 and the strike of 50 our margin of safety.
B trades at 50, but its estimated value is near 38, and profit forecasts are still falling, so even 38 could be too high. You would be agreeing to buy, at 50, something an outside estimate says is worth 38. There is no gap. There is a gap the wrong way. B pays more, and the quote does not tell you why. The estimate is a separate piece of evidence, and it says 38.
When the case for A stops being valid
Before going on, turn the screen on A. Suppose the next results are bad and the estimate is cut, from near 68 to below 50. A no longer passes the screen that put it on your list. You hold shares at 40 that you paid 50 for, and the reason you agreed to buy them is gone. An ownership case can stop being valid, and when it does, the questions that follow are not about selection: how large the position was, and what you do now. That is where the method goes next, and this article stops.
What you are holding at 40
Now both stocks are at 40, both puts have been assigned, and you check both estimates again. Say they have held, A near 68 and B near 38. Estimates get revised, so that is an assumption, and you make it out loud.
With A, you agreed to buy at 50, and that is what you paid. The market now says 40 and the outside estimate still says near 68. The price may keep falling. The estimate may be wrong. But you can say, in one sentence, why you are holding it.
With B, you also paid 50. The market says 40 and the estimate says near 38. The 115 you saved is real and it is yours. Now finish this sentence: I am holding B because. If the extra premium was your only reason for choosing B, the fall exposes the missing case for owning it.
It did not take the fall to see this. B failed on the day you were choosing. Not because it was going to fall; nobody knows that, and a stock valued at 38 can rally while a stock valued at 68 halves. It failed our rule for choosing what to sell a put on: be willing to own the shares at the strike. At 50, on a business valued near 38, you would not be, and no premium changes that.
Take both stocks down to 25 on the same day and B is still 115 ahead. The arithmetic will never rescue A. That was never the point. Both trades can leave you owning shares. Only A passed the screen we applied before selling, and the premium column cannot tell them apart.
What the 115 buys, and what it does not
In this example we accept 115 less premium because we would rather own A at 50 than B at 50. That is all it buys. This screen does not tell you how many puts to sell or what to do if the stock keeps falling, and those two decide whether a bad month is survivable. The arithmetic is unforgiving: lose 10 percent of a sum and the rest has to gain 11 percent to get even. Lose half and it has to double.
How many puts you sell decides how much a fall in one stock can hurt the whole account. The screen checks something else: whether you had a reason, apart from the premium, to own the shares at your strike. Both matter. This article is about the second.
The ownership screen, before you compare premiums
This is the first screen, not the whole trade decision. Timing, size and what to do if the stock keeps falling come after it, and are not covered here.
- Cover the premium column. For each stock, find an outside estimate of what the business is worth, and note the date it was made.
- Run the three checks on the estimate: its date, the direction of the forecasts behind it, and the range around it.
- If the stock is not trading below the estimate, it does not pass our screen. Skip it, whatever the put pays.
- If it passes, set your strike well below the estimate. The gap is your margin of safety.
- Ask the ownership question: if you were assigned at this strike, would you be willing to own this business through a bad month?
- Check the earnings date. If the company reports before the put expires, you wait. A report can gap a stock past any strike overnight, and no estimate helps with that.
- Only now compare premiums. If the richer put fails this screen, skip it. Take the other only after it passes the rest of your checks.
What this costs, and what it cannot do
You will turn down premium, sometimes a lot of it, and some weeks nothing on your list will pass. An estimate can be wrong, and it can be cut the week after you relied on it, so treat it as a range and leave room. A business can pass every check and still fall hard. The floor is a reason to own, not a limit on how far the price can go.
The premium pays you for the risk. It does not tell you whether to take it. Before your next put, cover the premium column and ask the one question that survives a fall: at 40, what will I be holding, and why?
The free guide
Would You Own It? The Ownership Test Behind Every Put You Sell. Six pages on the question that comes before any premium: whether you would be willing to own the business at all. When you confirm your email, Module 1 of the course, Options 101, opens on your dashboard as well.
About SafePremium Academy
SafePremium Academy teaches a rules-based framework for selling options premium: how candidates are selected, how exposure is sized, and how a position is defended when it moves against you. The method is what survived after years of testing approaches that did not. We trade it ourselves, with real capital today.
Educational content only. Not investment advice. Options involve risk of loss.